I was a little surprised that everyone got in to it at least a little bit - it was awesome! We paired that with a Valentine's Day themed White Elephant Gift Exchange. The gifts included everything from a giant blow up heart to a pink stuffed teddy bear named Poopsie... We had fun, so I decided to do it again this year.
Because we are all responsible adults and have to wake up early on Mondays, we had our party on a Sunday... Before everyone arrived, I set out some craft papers, stickers, ribbons, scissors, glue, pens, tape, etc.
We packed up most of the supplies we used last year in one box, so it was easy to pull it out again this year. I bought these cute foam glitter heart stickers at a sale after Valentine's Day last year and kept them for us to use this year.